top of page
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube

Penal order of less than 90 daily rates: Why naturalization can still fail

5 minutes ago
6 min read

The 90-daily-rate threshold under § 12a Abs. 1 S. 1 Nr. 2 StAG (German Nationality Act) is widely known: convictions of up to 90 daily rates (Tagessätze) are, as a rule, disregarded for naturalization, and only above that is a person no longer regarded as of good standing (unbescholten). What is often overlooked is that this threshold can be reached not only through a single conviction, but also through the addition of several sentences (§ 12a Abs. 1 S. 3 StAG). A penal order (Strafbefehl) of less than 90 daily rates can therefore preclude German citizenship for years – even for people who never thought of themselves as having a criminal record.


Initial case: Penal order of 80 daily rates

As a hard-working, high-achieving individual, you made a mistake with your paperwork. You now receive a penal order (Strafbefehl) by mail accusing you of a violation of § 95 Abs. 2 Nr. 2 AufenthG (Residence Act). A penal order is a written criminal penalty the court imposes without a trial. If you do not object within two weeks, it becomes final, like a judgment (§ 410 Abs. 3 StPO). The penalty is 80 daily rates. You are inclined not to file an objection (Einspruch) and to let the two-week deadline expire (§ 410 Abs. 1 S. 1 StPO, Code of Criminal Procedure) – "it's below the 90-daily-rate threshold, so no problem."


Before making this decision, you should definitely check whether there has already been a conviction – otherwise a painful surprise awaits. In our example there is one: 40 daily rates three years ago, because you drove with a foreign driver's license that was no longer valid (§ 21 StVG, Road Traffic Act). Together, that is 120 daily rates.


Does the old conviction still count?

Yes, as long as it is neither expunged nor eligible for expungement in the Federal Central Register (Bundeszentralregister) (§ 51 Abs. 1 BZRG; BVerwG, Judgment of 20.03.2012 – 5 C 5.11, para. 32), because


Convictions that have been expunged or are to be expunged from the Federal Central Register (BZRG) cannot, for example, be included in the calculation, nor can violations of fine regulations.

(unofficial translation of NK-AuslR/Geyer, 3rd ed. 2023, StAG § 12a para. 10)


It therefore depends on exactly how far in the past the earlier conviction lies. For a fine of up to 90 daily rates, the expungement period is five years from the date of conviction (§ 46 Abs. 1 Nr. 1 lit. a BZRG). If a new conviction is added before then, none is expunged until the new one, too, is eligible for expungement (§ 47 Abs. 3 S. 1 BZRG). In the example, the 40 daily rates therefore count not only for two more years, but presumably until 2031.


Does a sentence of 90 daily rates appear in the certificate of good conduct (Führungszeugnis)?

For naturalization, this is irrelevant.

The naturalization authority (Einbürgerungsbehörde) sees the Federal Central Register (§ 41 Abs. 1 Nr. 6 BZRG; more on naturalization with a criminal record (Einbürgerung mit Vorstrafen)). A fine of up to 90 daily rates is not entered in the simple certificate of good conduct if it is the only conviction. In our example case there is a prior entry, so the conviction of 80 daily rates would be recorded.


When is the exceedance only "minor"?

According to administrative practice, up to 111 daily rates; according to case law, at least no longer at 120 daily rates. Under § 12a Abs. 1 S. 4 StAG, minor exceedances may be disregarded, both for a single conviction and for the sum of several convictions.


In 2012, the Federal Administrative Court (judgment of March 20, 2012 - 5 C 5.11) held that an exceedance by one third was no longer minor. For 90 daily rates this means: from 120 daily rates at the latest, there is no longer a minor exceedance. A single fine of 120 daily rates would thus preclude naturalization just as much as our 40 plus 80 daily rates.


According to the Federal Ministry of the Interior's application notes on the StAG (Anwendungshinweise des BMI, as of 1 May 2025) the upper limit for minor status is 21 daily rates, or three weeks above the de-minimis threshold (section 12a.1.4), i.e., 111 daily rates. So a maximum of 71 could be added to our 40 daily rates.


So up to 111 daily rates is no problem?

No, just a somewhat smaller problem. Where a minor exceedance exists, it may be disregarded. Legal scholarship assumes this should be the case


if the foreigner's social prognosis is positive and his integration is otherwise good (...). However, naturalization should be excluded at least where the person concerned was sentenced to a prison term that was not suspended on probation (...). Where there is a risk of repetition, the public interest will as a rule speak against naturalization, even where the offenses are minor.

(unofficial translation of BeckOK AuslR/Kluth, 47th ed. 1.1.2026, StAG § 12a para. 9)


This gives your lawyer several points to work with. For skilled workers (Fachkräfte), there is plenty of room to argue via the profession – and a supportive letter from the employer can help in an individual case.


And what if the total is significantly higher?

Then there remains discretionary naturalization (Ermessenseinbürgerung) on grounds of public interest (§ 8 Abs. 2 StAG; Federal Administrative Court, judgment of March 20, 2012 – 5 C 5.11, para. 38). Case law requires more than simply living, working and paying taxes in Germany for a long time (for example OVG des Saarlandes Higher Administrative Court of Saarland, judgment of June 28, 2012 – 1 A 35/12).


The commentary literature states the following:


A public interest in naturalization despite exceeding the de-minimis threshold is recognized in case law where, on the specific facts, there is a specific state interest in the naturalization that sets the case apart from the average naturalization application and can, by way of exception, justify naturalizing the foreigner despite a lack of a clean record.

(unofficial translation of Hailbronner/ Kau/ Gnatzy/ Weber/ Hailbronner, 8th ed. 2026, StAG § 12a para. 12)


The message is clear: Anyone who significantly exceeds the de-minimis threshold needs more than successful integration; they need a special interest on the part of the state in their naturalization. This could be conceivable, for example, in the case of top athletes, major entrepreneurs, or outstanding figures in the cultural sector.

The German Bundestag's Research Service (Wissenschaftlicher Dienst, WD 3 - 3000 - 071/24) puts it this way:


It requires that the applicant's naturalization be "desirable" on the basis of general political, economic or cultural considerations.

(unofficial translation)


If this route is to be attempted, work must begin very early and with the utmost dedication. Good cooperation between lawyer and client is indispensable here.


What can you do within those two weeks?

File an objection, and do so with a clear objective. The best outcome is no conviction: only intent is punishable, a mere error in the paperwork is not. A discontinuation of proceedings (Einstellung), for instance against a monetary condition (§ 153a StPO), also does not count. The second-best result is fewer daily rates: with no more than 50, the total stays at 90; with no more than 71, the route via minor status remains open.


If the new offense was committed before the earlier conviction and the old fine has not yet been fully paid, an aggregate sentence must be formed (Gesamtstrafe, § 55 Abs. 1 StGB, Criminal Code). It is always lower than the sum (§ 54 Abs. 2 S. 1 StGB), and only it counts for naturalization.


The court may then also impose a higher penalty (§ 411 Abs. 4 StPO), but the objection can be withdrawn until the start of the main hearing (§ 411 Abs. 3 StPO). So: file within the deadline, obtain access to the file (Akteneinsicht), then decide.


Conclusion

The earlier the legal work begins, the more options and opportunities there are. Anyone who comes to Germany as a skilled worker or high achiever and seeks German citizenship should take state sanctions seriously as a matter of principle. Deal with criminal allegations no less professionally than you do in every other area of life.



Quick answer

  • Can a criminal record (Vorstrafe) prevent German naturalization – even a penal order (Strafbefehl) under 90 daily rates?

    Yes, if an earlier, not-yet-expunged conviction is added and the total exceeds 90 daily rates.


  • What can you do within the two weeks?

    File an objection in time, obtain access to the file, then decide on the goal.


  • Does an old fine still count?

    Yes, as long as it is not expunged in the Federal Central Register. A new conviction postpones the expungement of the old one.


  • Are 90 daily rates a criminal record?

    For naturalization, up to 90 daily rates are harmless; only above that is a person no longer regarded as of good standing.


  • Is a Strafbefehl a criminal record (Vorstrafe)?

    Yes. An unchallenged penal order becomes a final conviction and is recorded in the Federal Central Register. For naturalization it counts once it – alone or added together – exceeds 90 daily rates.


  • What do 90 daily rates mean?

    A fine measured in daily rates, where the number reflects the seriousness of the offense and the amount reflects income (§ 40 StGB).


  • When should you contact a lawyer?

    When a penal order lands in your mailbox: immediately! The two-week objection deadline is already running.


For an initial consultation with a German citizenship lawyer, feel free to use our contact form.


As of November 2026 · Professionally reviewed by: Visaguard partner lawyer

bottom of page