Problematic: Identity and passport when naturalizing Iraqi children born in Germany

All requirements are met, the documents are complete – and yet the process is stalled. The naturalization authority is demanding [something] for those born in Germany. Iraqi children Passports , although the entire The family is recognized as refugees and only possesses the blue travel document. It is not uncommon for it to be suggested that the father should travel to Iraq to obtain the to register children there. Our clear assessment: Such a demand is often legally contestable. Is obtaining a passport for the If the placement of children is deemed unacceptable, the authorities must verify their identity using the lower-level steps of the tiered model developed by the Federal Administrative Court. Crucially, this unacceptability must be specifically justified and substantiated – general objections are insufficient.
Why does the naturalization authority even require a passport?
After Section 10 paragraph 1 sentence 1 of the Nationality Act establishes the Naturalization requires that identity and The applicants' nationality must be clarified. This also applies to minors. Children who are looking for According to Section 10 Paragraph 2 of the Nationality Act, they can be naturalized together with their parents. With its ruling of December 18, 2025 (1 C 27.24), the Federal Administrative Court clarified its tiered model for establishing identity: Proof is primarily and generally provided by a To carry a passport . Only when a If obtaining a passport is objectively impossible or subjectively unreasonable, other official documents and further evidence may be used. A sworn affidavit is not sufficient according to the ruling. The court expressly emphasizes this. The court also ruled that identity verification is not waived even for recognized refugees.
In our daily practice, we observe that naturalization authorities – including the The Berlin State Office for Immigration has been insisting on the presentation of national passports much more frequently since this ruling, sometimes citing the decision schematically.
Does this ruling even apply to children born in Germany?
From our perspective, only to a limited extent. The Federal Administrative Court had to decide on the case of an adult man who possessed documents from his country of origin and refused to apply for a passport. The ruling establishes the order in which evidence must be examined. However, it does not answer the question of whether Children born in Germany who have never had contact with authorities in their country of origin must first be registered there in order to even have a A passport can be issued.
In these The situation is fundamentally different for children : their birth is registered by a German registry office, their travel document has been issued by German authorities, and their protection status is regularly derived via family refugee protection. Section 26 of the Asylum Act (AsylG) refers to the parents. An important detail from practice: We always check whether the German birth certificate contains a restrictive clause because the parents' identity was not proven at the time of registration. If such a clause is missing, the certificate has considerably higher evidentiary value than many case workers assume.
When is obtaining an Iraqi passport unreasonable?
It depends on the individual case – and above all on the reason for the flight. Family . Administrative courts are increasingly differentiating between cases where persecution originated from the Iraqi state itself or from non-state actors. For example, in July 2026, the Cologne Administrative Court ruled that obtaining a passport from the embassy was reasonable for an Iraqi refugee who had fled ISIS, not state persecution. However, someone who has fled from state authorities cannot generally be expected to contact them directly.
The expectation that the father should travel to Iraq in person is particularly problematic. Voluntary return to the country of origin or acceptance of a national passport may be possible after... Section 72 Paragraph 1 of the Asylum Act leads to the termination of refugee status. An authority cannot require parents to jeopardize their own protected status in order to fulfill their obligation to cooperate with their children. to fulfill requirements for children . The same applies to arrangements where a substitute travel document is to be obtained first – in practice, these are hardly feasible without changing the status of the entire family. To endanger family . Furthermore: The exhibition of Iraqi Passports for the Children themselves can be affected by their own refugee protection.
What other forms of evidence are acceptable?
Is the If a passport is deemed unreasonable, the next steps are considered. These primarily include German civil status documents, travel documents, documents from the parents' asylum proceedings, and the parents' identity documents, provided their own identity has already been established. This last point is often overlooked: If the identity of the father and mother is proven, the identity of a child born in Germany can be established. In many cases, the child's history can be traced seamlessly through the birth certificate.
Our experience shows that authorities are significantly more likely to accept secondary evidence if it is presented not piecemeal, but in a structured written submission. This includes a comprehensible explanation of why a Pass for each individual The child's situation is deemed unacceptable, with reference to relevant case law. However, our observations show that the practice in Berlin is not uniform and noticeably depends on the individual caseworker.
Are the children perhaps already German?
Before even talking about When passports are disputed, it warrants an examination, which is surprisingly often neglected. After According to § 4 para. 3 of the German Nationality Act (StAG), a person born in Germany acquires child the German Citizenship is granted automatically if one parent had been legally resident in Germany for five years at the time of the child's birth and held an unlimited residence permit. If one parent already had a permanent residence permit at the time of the child's birth, the naturalization process may be shorter for that parent. The child has finished. With siblings born in different years, different results are not uncommon.
What should families do now – and what should they avoid?
Many affected individuals react to the letter from the authorities in one of three ways: They wait, they contact the Iraqi embassy themselves, or they rely on general information from the internet. All three paths carry risks. Those who wait risk rejection for lack of cooperation. Those who contact the embassy without advice or even travel to Iraq potentially jeopardize the protection status of the entire country. Family . And standard information takes neither the specific reason for fleeing nor current administrative practice into account.
It is advisable to submit a written, legally sound statement to the authority. If the proceedings remain stalled without sufficient reason, an action for failure to act can be filed after three months. Section 75 of the Administrative Court Procedure Act (VwGO) may be considered. If the application is rejected, the claim can be pursued by an action for performance. enforce the court .
Conclusion
The obligation to verify identity also applies to Children of recognized refugees – but this is not a license for demands that would jeopardize their protected status Endangering family . Whether the procurement of Iraqi Whether or not a passport is deemed reasonable depends largely on the reason for fleeing, the existing German documents, and the parents' immigration history. As a law firm specializing in citizenship and immigration law in Berlin, we provide support in these matters. Families in exactly this situation. This ranges from checking whether the Children who are already German citizens, regarding the statement to the State Office for Immigration up to the point of legal action. If you need a lawyer for If you are seeking naturalization in Berlin, please contact us before contacting the authorities of your country of origin.




