.png)
Prospects of success for inaction lawsuits in Munich (District Administration Office (KVR))
- Mirko Vorreuter
- 1 day ago
- 3 min read
For many Munich residents, the path to German citizenship involves a long wait at the District Administration Office (KVR) . Despite submitted documents and fulfilled requirements , years often pass without a decision being issued. In our law firm, we repeatedly see cases where naturalization applications have remained unprocessed for four years. Frustration is high when, even after filing an action for failure to act pursuant to Section 75 of the Administrative Court Procedure Act (VwGO) , no immediate decision is made, and the authorities only react under the pressure of legal proceedings. In Munich, a specific pattern emerges: progress is often only achieved after a date for an oral hearing at the Administrative Court has been set.
The action for failure to act at the Administrative Court of Munich
An action for failure to act is a legitimate means of compelling the KVR (Munich's Citizenship and Registration Office) to make a decision. According to Section 75 of the German Administrative Court Procedure Act (VwGO) , an action can be brought if the authority has failed to decide on an application within a reasonable timeframe without sufficient cause. Our experience shows that the Munich Administrative Court (VG München) orders the City of Munich to bear the costs of the proceedings in cases where no processing has taken place for years . Actions for failure to act against the KVR are therefore often successful. However, a successful action unfortunately does not automatically guarantee naturalization . Often, the authority merely promises to make a decision promptly during the proceedings, whereupon the action is declared settled. While this ends the inaction, it does not guarantee a positive decision, especially if complex legal issues remain unresolved.
Strict requirements for identity verification in Munich
Especially for applicants from countries with complex documentation requirements, the hurdle of identity verification at the Munich Administrative Court is extremely high. The relevant chambers in Munich are considered very strict. However, an important strategic approach at the Munich Administrative Court arises when the KVR (Munich's Department of Public Order) has neglected fundamental procedural steps. We know from court practice that a so-called action for a decision on inaction is particularly likely to succeed when even the necessary security checks have not yet been initiated . The court often takes the view that an application for a decision is admissible if the authority has not even begun the essential investigation of the facts. In such situations, the court acts as a corrective to the authority's inactivity and compels the KVR to finally conduct the proceedings properly.
Conclusion: Strategic planning is key.
An action for failure to act against the city of Munich is an effective instrument to break years of stagnation. However, it carries risks if the substantive legal situation is problematic. In Munich, while the administrative court theoretically replaces the authority's decision, in practice the process often relies on an assurance from the authority during the proceedings. Anyone filing a lawsuit should therefore ensure that all necessary documents for naturalization are available, so that despite successfully ending the inaction, they don't end up without a naturalization certificate.
How we as a law firm can help with VisaGuard
The specific circumstances of Munich and the strict stance of the Munich Administrative Court (VG München) necessitate specialized legal support. Through our VisaGuard platform , we assist you in strategically increasing pressure on the Munich Citizens' Registration Office (KVR München). We review your file for unused investigation periods and missing security checks to prepare a well-founded action for failure to act. Simultaneously, we prepare you for the stringent requirements of document verification, ensuring your action not only ends the inaction but also leads you to your goal: German citizenship. We competently represent your interests before the Munich Administrative Court and ensure the authority takes responsibility for its inaction.
