Shortening the re-entry ban: When an application under Section 11 of the Residence Act is successful

Anyone who has had to leave Germany after deportation, expulsion, or a significant overstay of the departure deadline faces the question of whether this re-entry ban can be shortened. The law explicitly provides for this possibility. In practice, however, the process is considerably more difficult than many online guides suggest. We explain how the procedure works, which grounds are actually valid, and where the typical pitfalls lie.
What are the legal implications of a re-entry ban?
The term "re-entry ban" is colloquial. The Residence Act refers to an entry and residence ban according to Section 11 of the Residence Act. Such a ban must be issued against a foreigner who has been expelled, deported, or removed from Germany ( Section 11, Paragraph 1 of the Residence Act ). The consequences are comprehensive: The person concerned may neither enter nor remain in Germany, and may not be granted a residence permit, even if they would otherwise be entitled to one. An entry ban thus blocks even the most meticulously planned entry . Visa for a highly qualified person skilled worker .
The authorities must set a time limit for the ban ex officio; the time limit only begins upon departure ( § 11 para. 2 of the Residence Act ). The length of the ban is at their discretion. In principle, the time limit may only exceed five years if it is based on a criminal conviction or a serious threat to public safety and order; it should not exceed ten years (§ 11 para. 3 of the Residence Act). Anyone who significantly exceeds a departure deadline set for them may also be subject to an entry ban pursuant to § 11 para. 6 of the Residence Act.
Is it possible to have the entry ban shortened retroactively?
Yes. According to Section 11 Paragraph 4 Sentence 1 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG), an entry and residence ban can be lifted or its duration shortened to protect the legitimate interests of the foreigner or if the purpose of the ban no longer requires it. There is no specific form for this. The application can be submitted informally, at any time, and even from abroad. The responsible authority is usually the The immigration authority that issued the ban, in Berlin, is therefore the State Office for Immigration ( LEA ). If the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees has ordered the ban in the asylum procedure, the responsibility lies with them (§ 75 No. 12 AufenthG).
Section 11, paragraph 4, sentence 2 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG) contains a discretionary provision: If the requirements for a humanitarian residence permit under Chapter 2, Section 5 are met, the prohibition should be lifted. However, this rule does not apply to classic labor migration. Furthermore, the decision must take into account whether the person concerned has complied with their obligation to leave the country within the prescribed period (Section 11, paragraph 4, sentence 3 of the German Residence Act). Informal does not mean hopeless, but neither does it mean that a short letter is sufficient.
Which reasons convince the authorities and which do not?
Herein lies the crux of the problem. Shortening the term is a discretionary decision, and the authorities apply strict standards. It is not enough that living circumstances have improved or that the applicant credibly assures them that they will adhere to all rules in the future. Truly compelling reasons are required, ideally reasons that arose only after the original decision to set the term. Anyone who merely reiterates what the authorities already knew when setting the term will generally fail.
Many affected individuals are hoping for a job or apprenticeship offer. This is understandable, but rather difficult in practice. Authorities regularly argue that the individual's economic interests take a back seat to the purpose of the ban and that an apprenticeship or job can still be started even after the deadline has passed. The ban is specifically intended to prevent a violation of immigration law from going unpunished. The interest of an employer in finding a sought-after employee also plays a role. In our experience, the need to quickly hire a skilled worker rarely outweighs the need for a quick response.
Surprisingly for many: Even family reasons rarely lead to success. The relationship to spouses or to the Children were regularly taken into account when setting the deadline, because Article 6 of the German Basic Law and Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights were already factored into the balancing of interests at that stage. The authorities then point out that contact with the Family ties can be maintained through visits abroad and modern means of communication. The situation can be different if the family circumstances have changed significantly, for example, through the birth of a child. child with German Nationality , a serious illness, or the need to care for a close relative.
Better chances often exist with the second criterion, namely when the purpose of the prohibition no longer exists. For example, if a crime was committed a long time ago, the probationary period was successfully completed, and there are no new incidents, it can be convincingly demonstrated that there is no longer any danger. In our experience, it also has a positive effect if outstanding deportation costs (§§ 66, 67 of the German Residence Act) have been paid; outstanding claims will inevitably be addressed in the subsequent visa application process.
What alternatives are there for short stays?
Anyone who needs to enter Germany for a specific reason should be aware of the entry permit under Section 11 Paragraph 8 of the Residence Act. This permit allows, in exceptional cases, short-term entry into Germany if compelling reasons necessitate the person's presence or if refusal would constitute undue hardship, for example, in the case of a funeral, a court appearance, or the birth of a child. Child . The permission to enter does not lift the prohibition and is not a stepping stone to permanent residence.
Why do so many self-initiated applications fail?
Those affected essentially have three options: wait, submit an application themselves, or seek legal representation. Waiting isn't always the wrong approach. If the remaining validity period is short and there are no compelling reasons for delay, we sometimes even advise using the time to thoroughly prepare for the subsequent visa application process. However, submitting an application independently is risky. We frequently see emotional letters that describe the personal situation in detail but fail to meet the legal requirements of Section 11 Paragraph 4 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG). Such a rejection remains on file, and a second application without new information has little chance of success.
We therefore regularly begin by reviewing the files. Only the complete notice of limitation reveals the considerations the authority took into account and where new arguments can be made. Furthermore, we know from hundreds of cases that applications remain with Immigration authorities often let applications lie dormant for months. After three months without sufficient justification, an action for failure to act under Section 75 of the Administrative Court Procedure Act (VwGO) can be considered; if this is rejected, an action for performance can be brought before the administrative court. Another practical point not mentioned in any commentary: Even after the deadline has passed, the SIS alert is not always deleted promptly. Anyone who then appears at the consulate without proof of identity is in for a nasty surprise.
For employers and HR departments, this means: Anyone who, for example, US Anyone wishing to hire a software developer with a previous entry ban needs a realistic timeline. Often, a combination is advisable: a strongly justified application for a reduction of the ban and, in parallel, preparation for an accelerated skilled worker procedure under Section 81a of the German Residence Act, which can begin immediately after the ban is lifted.
Conclusion
The reduction or lifting of a re-entry ban can be applied for informally and at any time according to Section 11 Paragraph 4 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG). However, the hurdles are high: An apprenticeship, a job offer, or family ties are usually not sufficient on their own, because the authorities consider these aspects either secondary or already taken into account. Applications that precisely address the legal requirements by highlighting new, significant facts are most successful. Anyone affected by an entry ban, or who, as an employer, has an affected employee, should apply for a re-entry ban. If you're looking to hire a skilled worker , you should have your application reviewed by the relevant authorities before even contacting them. Get in touch with us: We'll analyze your file and develop a realistic strategy.



