The Dresden Administrative Court also considers border controls unlawful.

For more than three years, the German Federal Police have been conducting checks at the borders with Poland and the Czech Republic. For just as long, courts have ruled that they are not permitted to do so in this manner. On November 11, 2026, the Dresden Administrative Court became the latest court to rule that the entry controls at the Saxon borders violate EU law. Nevertheless, the checks continue. For travelers without valid residence permits, the border thus remains a real risk. We therefore recommend: Before every trip to Prague, Wrocław, or Szczecin, check whether your passport and residence documents are sufficient for re-entry. And carefully document every check.
What did the Dresden Administrative Court decide regarding border controls?
The court had to decide on two identity checks carried out by the Federal Police. One took place in autumn 2024 at the border with Poland, the other in spring 2026 at the border with the Czech Republic. Such a check is considered complete upon its conclusion. Legally, therefore, the case concerns a declaratory judgment action (analogous to Section 113 Paragraph 1 Sentence 4 of the German Administrative Court Procedure Act ): The court subsequently determines whether the measure was lawful. In both cases, the answer was no.
The Federal Police base identity checks at the border on Section 23 Paragraph 1 Number 2 of the Federal Police Act (BPolG) , i.e., on the control of cross-border traffic. However, this authority only applies if the internal border controls themselves are compatible with the Schengen Borders Code . If they are not, the individual check is also invalid.
The written grounds for the judgment are still pending, but the court has granted leave to appeal. However, the line of jurisprudence has been the same for years. The European Court of Justice clarified as early as 2022 that a member state may not make internal border controls permanent through successive extensions (Judgment of 26 April 2022, C-368/20). The Bavarian Administrative Court , the Koblenz Administrative Court, and the Munich Administrative Court followed this precedent in 2025 and 2026.
Why do these controls violate Schengen law?
The principle of freedom of movement in Europe is clear: within the Schengen Area, no border checks are carried out at internal borders (Article 22 of the Schengen Borders Code). Checks are only permitted as a temporary exception in the event of a serious threat to public order or internal security (Article 25 of the Schengen Borders Code). Regulation (EU) 2024/1717 reformed these rules and entered into force on July 10, 2024. Since then, the standard duration is two years. Only in exceptional circumstances are two further extensions of six months each possible, for a maximum total of three years (Article 25a of the Schengen Borders Code). Each extension must be justified by the member state to the European Commission with a robust risk assessment.
Border controls have been in place at the Polish and Czech borders since October 2023, and at all German land borders since September 16, 2024. The Federal Ministry of the Interior has now notified the EU Commission that these controls will continue until March 15, 2027. Brussels had already deemed the previous extension insufficiently justified. From our perspective, the legal situation is not unclear; it is being politically ignored. After each new setback, the Federal Government refers to higher authorities and continues with the controls unchanged. This demonstrates how little the legal rulings actually influence the Ministry.
Who are affected by border controls in practice?
EU citizens and holders of a valid residence permit show their ID and continue their journey. The situation becomes critical for a group that is rarely mentioned in public debate: third-country nationals who have entered without a visa and have not yet received their residence permit. This primarily affects nationals of the USA , Great Britain , Canada, Australia, Japan, Israel, New Zealand, and South Korea. According to Section 41 Paragraph 1 of the German Residence Ordinance (AufenthV), they are permitted to enter Germany without a visa and apply for a residence permit directly in Germany, for example, as skilled workers , freelancers , or for family reunification. The application must be submitted within 90 days of entry ( Section 41 Paragraph 3 AufenthV ).
The problem: The 90 visa-free days within a 180-day period apply to the entire Schengen Area. If these days are used up before the Berlin Immigration Office has decided on the application, the stay is based solely on the legal fiction of continued residence under Section 81 Paragraph 3 of the German Residence Act . This makes the stay in Germany legal, nothing more. A weekend in Krakow or Prague used to go unnoticed. Now, the Federal Police are waiting on the way back.
Why is the fictitious residence permit often not accepted at the border?
This is the point we most frequently address in our consultations. There are two fundamentally different certificates of fictitious residence permits, distinguished only by a single checkmark on the form. Those who apply for an extension before the expiration of an existing permit receive a certificate according to Section 81 Paragraph 4 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG ). In this case, the existing permit remains valid, and travel, including re-entry, is generally possible. Those who entered Germany without a visa, however, receive a certificate according to Section 81 Paragraph 3 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG ). This certificate does not authorize re-entry into Germany. The Berlin authorities also clarify this in their own guidelines .
In practice, we encounter errors in both directions. Some officials don't even recognize a certificate issued under paragraph 4 and detain travelers for hours. Conversely, some clients travel with a certificate issued under paragraph 3, believing they have a residence permit. In the latter case, they face rejection and charges of illegal entry under Section 14, paragraph 1, number 2 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG) , which is a criminal offense under Section 95, paragraph 1, number 3 of the German Residence Act . Furthermore, many applicants in Berlin don't even have a certificate of deemed residence, but only an email confirming their appointment. This is worthless at the border. Criminal proceedings can also interfere with the ongoing proceedings at the immigration office.
What should those affected do after a border check?
The most common reaction is to wait and hope that the matter has no consequences. Often, this is the worst approach. It is equally risky to make statements to the Federal Police or other authorities on your own initiative. Standard information and legal tech services generally do not distinguish between the two fictional scenarios and are unfamiliar with Berlin's administrative practices.
We recommend two steps. First: document everything. Immediately note the date, time, location, and direction of travel, the police station, and, if possible, the names or badge numbers of the officers. Record which documents you presented and what you were told. Request copies of any transcripts or hearing forms and do not sign anything you do not understand. You are not obligated to comment on any alleged offense. Second: seek legal advice before taking any action. We will assess whether criminal proceedings are imminent and how this might affect your application. We will also determine whether a declaratory judgment action is worthwhile and whether the proceedings at the state office can be expedited so that you can travel freely again.
For employers and HR departments bringing new employees from the USA or Great Britain to Berlin, the following applies: Business trips to Schengen countries should only be planned once the title has been issued or it is certain that the 90 days will not be exceeded.
Conclusion: Illegal, but still reality
The Dresden ruling confirms an established legal precedent: the continuous border checks at Germany's internal borders are incompatible with Schengen law. As long as the German government persists with them, travelers must accept them. Anyone who has entered Germany without a visa and is awaiting their travel documents should check the legal status of their visa before each trip. If you have already been checked, document the incident and seek legal advice as soon as possible. VISAGUARD.Berlin can assist you from assessing your fitness to travel to representing you in court.
Further links




