top of page
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube

The Council of Experts recommends including Ukraine in the list of privileged states (§ 26 BeschV)

3 days ago
6 min read

On March 4, 2028, temporary protection for refugees from Ukraine will end. This means that the residence permits under Section 24 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG ) will expire for more than one million people in Germany on the same day. The Expert Council on Integration and Migration (SVR) has now proposed a concrete solution: The German government should include Ukraine in the list of countries covered by Section 26 Paragraph 1 of the Employment Ordinance (BeschV). Ukrainians could then receive a residence permit for employment purposes without having to be qualified as skilled workers . We believe this is the right approach. It removes these people from their special humanitarian status and focuses their residency on what most are already doing: working.


Why is temporary protection no longer sufficient?

Protection under EU Directive 2001/55/EC was intended as a temporary measure: quick, unbureaucratic, and without asylum procedures. The EU Council extended it again this summer with Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/1912, this time until March 4, 2028. After almost five years, however, "temporary" is merely a label for many of those affected. They work, pay social security contributions, speak German, and their children attend school here.


Legally, their residency still depends on a permit that ends with the protection it grants. Anyone who hasn't switched to a different residence permit by then becomes obligated to leave the country. According to figures provided to the Bundestag by the German government, at the end of 2025, of the approximately 1.08 million people who had received a residence permit under Section 24 of the German Residence Act , only about 19,000 held a permit for other reasons. That's a rate of less than two percent.


Why do so many people fail when transitioning to a skilled worker qualification?

The traditional pathways, namely Sections 18a and 18b of the German Residence Act (AufenthG) for skilled workers or the EU Blue Card under Section 18g of the German Residence Act , require a recognized or comparable qualification and qualified employment. In our consultations, we see two groups in particular who regularly fail to meet these requirements.


On the one hand, there are well-educated Ukrainians working below their skill level: the teacher in the service industry, the civil engineer in a warehouse, the lawyer in administrative support. Their degrees are not recognized, and their current jobs are not considered qualified employment under the law. On the other hand, there are those employed in unskilled jobs in logistics, catering, or care work who earn their own living but cannot demonstrate formal qualifications. For both groups, current legislation offers little reliable recourse.


Furthermore, there is a hurdle within the law itself. Section 19f Paragraph 1 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG) excludes holders of certain EU-harmonized protection titles, including the Blue Card. While the Federal Ministry of the Interior clarified in August 2025 that a change is possible as long as both titles are not held simultaneously, in our practice the Berlin State Office for Immigration (LEA) still requires applicants to first obtain a residence permit under Section 18b of the Residence Act before issuing the Blue Card. Those unaware of this submit the wrong application and lose months.


What would the inclusion in Section 26 Paragraph 1 of the Employment Ordinance change?

Section 26 Paragraph 1 of the Employment Ordinance (BeschV) is the so-called "Best Friends" list. For nationals of Andorra, Australia, Israel, Japan, Canada, the Republic of Korea, Monaco, New Zealand, San Marino, the United Kingdom, and the USA , the Federal Employment Agency can approve any employment, regardless of qualifications or the employer's location. Together with Section 19c Paragraph 1 of the Residence Act (AufenthG), this results in a separate residence permit for employment purposes.


For Ukrainians, this would mean no recognition procedure, no salary threshold as with the Blue Card, and even unskilled labor would be possible. The priority check, which the regulation actually stipulates, has not been carried out by the Federal Employment Agency since November 2023 due to an internal directive. The check essentially focuses on whether the working conditions correspond to those of comparable domestic employees. The general requirements for granting a residence permit under Section 5 of the Residence Act (AufenthG) naturally still apply, such as a valid passport , a secure livelihood , and no grounds for deportation. Because the employer can also be based abroad, secondments between Ukraine and Germany would also be possible, for example, for German-Ukrainian companies involved in reconstruction or the defense industry.

The decisive advantage: residency is then based on employment and no longer on the need for protection. People leave their special humanitarian status without losing anything. And they gain a perspective that, via Section 9 of the Residence Act, can develop in the medium term into a permanent residence permit.


Why is Ukraine an obvious candidate?

The list was never purely a labor market instrument, but rather an expression of particularly close ties. South Korea was added in 2013 at the initiative of the German states in the Bundesrat (Federal Council), based on trade, investment, and political proximity. The same arguments can be made for Ukraine today. It is an EU accession candidate, closely linked to the single market through an association agreement with a free trade zone, and Ukrainian citizens already travel visa-free to the Schengen Area with biometric passports. The German Bar Association also called for its inclusion as early as 2025.


Politically, this solution is streamlined. A separate law just for Ukrainians would have little chance of passing under the current coalition. However, the federal government can amend the list of countries by statutory order pursuant to Section 42 of the Residence Act , provided the Federal Council approves. There is currently a window of opportunity for this. On November 4, 2026, the Federal Cabinet adopted the Ninth Ordinance Amending the Employment Ordinance, which halves the quota for the Western Balkans Regulation to 25,000 approvals per year starting in 2027. This ordinance is currently before the Federal Council for approval. The states could use this opportunity to add Ukraine to the list, as they did with Korea.


What should Ukrainians and employers do now?

A recommendation is not yet legally binding, and whether Ukraine will actually be admitted remains to be seen. Our most important advice is therefore: Don't wait for politicians. Anyone who meets the requirements for a skilled worker qualification, the Blue Card, or another residence permit should apply for the change while their qualification under Section 24 of the German Residence Act is still valid. As March 2028 approaches, the appointment calendars of immigration authorities are becoming increasingly full, and the Berlin Initial Reception Center (LEA) is already operating at its limit.


The same applies to HR departments. If you employ Ukrainian staff, you should now check who qualifies for which job title. A clearly worded employment contract with a well-defined job description and a market-standard salary often determines whether an application under Section 18b of the German Residence Act (AufenthG) is successful. For employees without recognized qualifications, it is worthwhile to simultaneously initiate the recognition of their Ukrainian degree. And those who don't yet fit into any category should closely monitor developments surrounding Section 26 of the German Employment Ordinance (BeschV) so that the application can be submitted immediately as soon as the amendment comes into effect.


Standard information from the internet or submitting an application independently often won't get you very far during these transitions. The differences between the federal states, Berlin's special procedures, and the correct order of applications aren't covered in any information leaflet. We support Ukrainian skilled workers, employees, and companies precisely through this process.


Conclusion

Including Ukraine in Section 26 Paragraph 1 of the Employment Ordinance would be a legally clear and politically feasible answer to a problem that will become acute no later than March 2028. It would prioritize labor migration instead of a long-term humanitarian stopgap. And it would offer prospects to hundreds of thousands who currently fail due to formal qualification barriers. Until politicians decide, however, the following applies: Anyone who can achieve a change of employment today should pursue it now.


Further links

bottom of page